If you look at bing you'll see that the water here maybe interment .... seasonal?

A closed way is an area if it is any number of things e.g. leisure=pitch, amenity=parking, building=*, natural=wood etc etc.. None of these would require area=yes. Simply - area=yes is, in most cases, not required.

OSMI showed an area problem that I fixed ... these seem to occur from time to time .. many with Id.

While I was fixing that I noted the area=yes tag .. JOSM validator will flag these .. possibly a \warning' rather than an 'error'. It is just something that you don't need to do, waste of time doing it.

Hi,

Welcome to OSM!

I am a bit puzzled by the node with the name 'Mayfair Property Group' umm other than the address .. it does not say what it is ... a real estate agent? The property owner?

-------------------------
There are more than one way of doing things...
I prefer to have the buildings as individual entries into OSM ... and than map the shops etc as nodes within the buildings. This matches the OSM 'guide' of 'one feature = one OSM entry'. Others put them all together as you have done.

Have fun, map what you enjoy.

reverted

reverted

area=yes is not required for multiplygon members.

Reverted owing to probable copyright issue.

Reverted owing to probable copyright issue.

Reverted owing to probable copyright issue.

Reverted owing to probable copyright issue.

As per my previous post - relation is not needed ...

Deleted relation and ways .. start again.

Hi,
The beaches that you are making do not need to be relations...

For example the relation made here 13939050 has 2 member ways both with roles 'outer'. Both these ways can be tagged as beaches ... and not need a relation.
The tag 'area=yes' is not required.. there are automatic tools that will delete them .. don't waste your time adding that tag.

Name tag for names only .. not descriptions..

See osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

Paths connect to the bridges! They don't stop some meters before them..

The 'roads' on the bridges' are of the same type as the 'roads' they connect to....

access=no?

Looks to be a new residential development ... access=private?

Hi,

What is the source of this information?
1) The name of 'Apew Park'?
2) the geometry of 'Apex Park'?

As the school is already mapped there is no need to tag the buildings as amenity=school.
The OSM guide is 'one feature' (school) 'one OSM entry'.

Hi,
Multipolygon relations outer ways cannot share segments. See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=150.74970&lat=-33.75020&zoom=17

As both ways used in the relation have no tags .. simply place the relevant tags on those ways and remove the relation. Much simpler.

Hi
I don't see vicmap - AERIAL_VG2020 in osm.wiki/Australian_data_catalogue#Victoria
Can you explain how this source meets OSM copyright requirements?