Hi,

For Way: 250644211 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

Hi,

Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

Hi,

Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

Hi,
You removed way/460671406 .. that forms the outer of a pedestrian area ...
relation/6805057 now only has an inner ...

Either remove the relation and have no pedestrian area here or reinstate the way you deleted.

Hi,
When you add a sporting pitch, add the sport that is played there. If more than one then sport=cricket;rugby for example.

I have added a few sports here. Bound to be some I have missed.

Boronia Gardens, Epping .. as a 'guest house' ...tagging for the render? More like a block of flats.

Oh,
One other thing.

The LPI base map shows these one way sections as being longer, I think those might be better approximations than what is present in OSM at the moment.

Strange!
Passengers would then exit on to the island .. and have to cross the road to get out.

Same thing on the other side with Way: Patrick Street Bus Tunnel (316000496)

That is not as safe as it could be if the ways were reversed - passengers would then exit to the curb and not be forced to cross the road. Is there a lift/stairway in the central island that overcomes this?

Sorry but I cannot use the busways document - it is copyright.

Moved. Possibly where they are.
Node has no physical tag so it will not render (show up on any map). I have added the physical tag shop=glass and removed the description tag.

If you look you'll find a few missing parks ... No 1 Lucinda Rd is a park on the LPI base map.

Hi,
Looks like your adding building in the Mosman area using the LPI Imagery.

Please use the comments section to say what your doing - makes it much easier to look back and check for yourself and others.

Most building are 'square' - i.e. they have right angled corners. The right angles are difficult to draw precisely so there is a tool in iD that you can use to 'square' them up = see https://learnosm.org/en/hot-tips/tracing-rectangular-buildings/

For change set comments see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Hi,
Would not these roads be classified as 'residential'? Certainly not 'secondary'!

Still have to deal with the proposed 'ephemeral' !
Then there is public transport v2 that I said i'd do a bit on...
lots 'to do' :)

Hi .. some thoughts.
Where a footway crosses a road there should be a node tagged highway=crossing and so on.
You also have tagged some of the nodes for the footway with tags for traffic lights .. the lights should be on there own individual nodes .. not doing double duty.

Thanks for spotting the mine. I did download a small area around it but obviously not big enough. Trouble is ..it does not render :)

Pass ... umm the OSM key mountain_pass is for a road. I am adverse to using the key natural as that confusingly applies to both 'natural' and 'unnatural' things so looses all meaning. OSM has pages for landuse and landcover .. the only remaining 'natural' item is landform (peaks, saddles etc) .. so I use that.

Hi,

The Cascase Rock to MacLaren Point path overlays several roads .. not good. Are there 'tracks' or 'paths', are motor vehicles allowed along them or not???

In short .. don't overlay one thing with another where they are in fact the same at that point.
If you want the route to show up then make a route relation and incorporate the segments into the route.

Hi
Overlapping ways is a no no.
You have placed footpaths on top of roads. Not good.

Hi,
You added Way: Glenfield Circuit (620649160) but this overlaps the existing Way: Briar Road (179372205).

Either it is Briar or Glenfield, but not both.

Use the tag noexit=yes to indicate there is no connection on the last node of Perrins lane, and possibly on Pinch lane too.

Hi,
If something has not been built then it does not exist. Use the planing or construction tags!

Mawarra St you have as two things - one overlayed on top of the other - one as a street the other as a cycleway. Err same thing on Albion and Macdonald. You may have them in other places. Find them and remove them. Make the roads part of the route.
I have removed the cycle way , but put the street in the route relation. Look at it and do the same elsewhere.

Note rcn goes on the route relation .. not on the ways.