Udarian's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 158370879 | sorry miss read the changeset comment, my brain registered "colour = White -> roof:colour = white" instead of what you write, my bad. I'll be more careful next time. |
|
| 158370879 | were these checked with aerial imagery before uploading, I ask because some of these may be the color of the walls of the building not the roof. |
|
| 157893178 | as mentioned previously we (OSM) don't have the right to use Waze data as a source and since that is the source for this commit I have reverted it, for more info see osm.wiki/Waze . |
|
| 157991991 | I saw a world spanning commit so I translated the changeset comment to see if it properly described what was in the commit and it wasn't so I left the comment about that and because from my experience when there are geographically large commits made by new contributors there's a high chance of the commits being vandalism so I translated some of the name changes to check. the changed names came out sus so I left a comment pointing out that there's possibly an issue here so that someone with more experience and knows the language can check them and see if they are vandalism. I just didn't call it vandalism from the get go since from other commits you seems to be mostly well intentioned so I left it implied. I was just tying to be nice about it, I always like to give others the benefit of the doubt on these things unless it is really clear what it is. it isn't ignorance to point out possible vandalism, the whole point of me pointing out that I don't know the language was to point out that there might be vandalism in this commit and other who know the language can fix any issues; ignorance would be me calling it vandalism without pointing out that I don't know the language.
|
|
| 157938999 | please respond |
|
| 157991655 | it seams like the changes made to the names of these countries translate to completely nonsensical things |
|
| 157991991 | next time can you please leave a better changeset comment, for m ore info see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments .
|
|
| 157987279 | I understand that, I was just making sure, but ya, feel free to change the name of that segment of old cutler. |
|
| 157980003 | did you use something like Bing streetside to see the signs or Waze again. |
|
| 157987279 | then we change the name of the road and close note/3071873 once that's done since the osmi issues were why I opened and kept open that note. also we cant use google as a source since google hasn't given us (OSM) the right to use their data in OSM so it cant be used as a source. |
|
| 157987279 | the problem with using "West Old Cutler Road" for the road name for addresses is that there is no road named like that in the area, its named "Old Cutler Road" not "West Old Cutler Road", so this causes data issues, for more info see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=addresses&lon=-80.36635&lat=25.56076&zoom=18&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=buildings%2Cbuildings_with_addresses%2Cpostal_code%2Centrances_deprecated%2Centrances%2Cno_addr_street%2Cstreet_not_found%2Cplace_not_found%2Cmisformatted_housenumber_lenient%2Cnodes_with_addresses_defined%2Cnodes_with_addresses_interpolated%2Cinterpolation%2Cinterpolation_errors%2Cconnection_lines%2Cnearest_points%2Cnearest_roads%2Cnearest_areas%2Caddrx_on_nonclosed_way%2Cbuildings%2Cbuildings_with_addresses%2Cpostal_code%2Centrances_deprecated%2Centrances%2Cno_addr_street%2Cstreet_not_found%2Cplace_not_found%2Cmisformatted_housenumber_lenient%2Cnodes_with_addresses_defined%2Cnodes_with_addresses_interpolated%2Cinterpolation%2Cinterpolation_errors%2Cconnection_lines%2Cnearest_points%2Cnearest_roads%2Cnearest_areas%2Caddrx_on_nonclosed_way . |
|
| 157978640 | did you use something like Bing streetside to see the signs or Waze again. |
|
| 157980003 | whats the source for this? |
|
| 157978640 | whats the source for this? |
|
| 157938999 | What’s the source for this? |
|
| 157893178 | wazes data is proprietary to them, aka they haven't given us (open street map) the right to use their data and thus we can't use their data as a source for contributions to OSM. doesn't matter what shows up on waze unless they give us (open street map) the explicit right to incorporate parts of their data into OSM we cant use waze as a source for commits. |
|
| 157901445 | next time please leave a better change set comment, for more info see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments, also I doubt that diet:pizza is the correct tagging to use in this
|
|
| 157901402 | the opening_hours tagging here is done incorrectly for more info see opening_hours=*. also the change set comment doesn't really tell me what you've done in the commit, for more info see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 157893178 | whats the source for this |
|
| 157696365 | I have looked at this changeset on OSMCha and this commit doesn't duplicate anything the way deleted in changeset/157835565 was elongated into that shape in changeset/157736989, so that duplicated isn't on me. all I did in this commit was updated the alignment of a few roads and streams and adding bridges and culverts were necessary. |