Udarian's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 144333076 | for way way/1052424905 wouldn't building=university be a better tag, I've never been there, I'm asking purely off of the name here. |
|
| 144336940 | first of all, welcome to OSM, as for "Do you have an easier method?" if your talking about iD, it is one of the simpler editors all together, the only simpler ones are for mobile (StreetComplete osm.wiki/StreetComplete and Every Door osm.wiki/Every_Door). from my knowledge iD is the simplest on desktop. There is one last point here, we are legally not allowed to use google as a source since their data is proprietary and we dont have the right to bring it into OSM, especially because OSM is licensed as ODbL and google is proprietary and they haven't given us the express rights to use their data. so from my understanding this commit is in violation of all of that. |
|
| 143992462 | again, it would be wonderfull if you could please elaborate on why you removed way way/1178243253. |
|
| 144449963 | sorry typo "public storage"
|
|
| 143992462 | also that removed way is also on the "Esri World Imagery" Ariel imagery and several others so unless this has changed over the last year I doubt that way/1178243253 is no longer there |
|
| 143992462 | again, can you please respond, my biggest worry is that the deletion of way/1178243253 is incorrect and I would like to figure this out ASAP. |
|
| 144260309 | I have a quick question?
if you have any questions you can just just respond as a comment here or as a message to me through the "Send Message" link on my user profile when logged in (@Udarian).
|
|
| 144220624 | also added new roundabout based on latest imagery |
|
| 144059613 | sorry didnt mean to add the last part, my bad, what I meant to put it: next time you commit try to keep you commits in various areas local (restrained to one geographic area like a city or town) as to keep the geographic area down, this makes it easier to review. |
|
| 144059613 | 2 points here, first, please next time try to keep you commits in various areas local (restrained to one geographic area like a city or town) as to keep the geographic area down, this makes it easier to review. Also please next time provide a change set comment describing what was done in the commit, for more information see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments for more details. |
|
| 143823733 | so, just to make sure we understand each other here; the edits on this commit (143823733) were good and should have been kept (I have since fixed the fact that this was reverted in a commit of my own), I had no issue with that. the only issue was with the fact that the change set comment (comment)=* inaccurately described what was done in the commit, thats it. |
|
| 144085570 | 2 points here, first, please next time try to keep you commits in various areas local (restrained to one geographic area like a city or town) as to keep the geographic area down, this makes it easier to review. Also please next time provide a change set comment describing what was done in the commit, for more information see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments for more details. |
|
| 143823733 | I was not pointing out "improper modifications", just that the comment=* could have been better. |
|
| 143823733 | I dont know if I was misunderstood, it is preferable for the traffic_signals to be at the lines on the roads were the cars should stop, what this commit actually did was correct, my original message on this commit was to do with the change set comment on this.
|
|
| 144117677 | sorry, bad change set comment, updated alignment of sidewalks based on newer imagery |
|
| 143992462 | please respond, it would be nice to get those clarifications. |
|
| 143992462 | I have a few notes here, first, next time please try and keep the geographic area down, this could have been done as 6 ish separate smaller commits and it would have made it easier to review/understand.
|
|
| 143823733 | wouldn't "updated traffic signals" be a better commit message since it better describes what was done in the commit since it wasn't stop signs that were added rather traffic signals. |
|
| 143819850 | when adding stop signs a better commit message would be "added stop sign" since you didn't change the alignment and because it better describes what was actually done in the commit. |
|
| 143726042 | wouldn't "added stop sign" be a better (better describes what was done in the commit) change set comment for this since that was what was done, since the actual alignment has not changed. |