OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
167974124

Yes, for relations only. Without baselines, drawing old boundaries in OHM is painful

168379271

Thank you so much for your service!

168218921

This is so bad I will have to revert it

167974124

Well, actually, I do have a few sources to back them up: Wikipedia, GADM and danhmuchanhchinh.gso.gov.vn. I will try my best to maintain them until all of them get imported into OHM

167974124

But I still miss the old communes TvT
How do I export them to a GeoJSON file of sort?

167974124

So old communes will be gone, I guess?

167974124

But if you can, please also improve the old ditricts & commune boundaries. Otherwise, you could just tag them as I wanted. In any case though, please don't delete these historical units

167959050

Guys, guys, keep calm, if these's consensus I will tag all of them with admin_level=6

167974124

Oh well, just tag these communes in Quang Ninh with boundary=historical first, then you can add new one as you wish. Note that I already added some new communes as per govt decisions in the province, so you better update them first rather than deleting them

167974124

Yes, bc I'm very enthusiastic about these; and to be fair, these boundaries will linger in people's mind for quite a long time (at least down to the districts), so these units may satisfy the attestation criterion of boundary=historical in OSM. That being said, if these is a way to magically bring them into OHM, I would be glad to do it

167974124

Why did you do this? It's not easy to redraw them in OHM without some mass import, whose practical method I have not found yet

167778240

And also, is there a way to import OSM data into OHM? I would feel safe to delete boundaries only when I could archive it there

167778240

Well, that is one way to do it, but without already established boundaries, it will be much more tedious. Also, if you change any other boundary in Quang Ninh Province, please tag it with boundary=historical instead of outright deleting it, because I do not want my hard work drawing these to be wasted so quickly...

167765837

REVERT THIS IMMEDIATELY

167518866

Please move old communes and wards into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)

167524119

Please move old communes and wards into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)

167530691

Please move old communes and wards into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)

167536983

Please add the old provinces into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)

167535766

Please move the old communes into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)

167525232

Please move the old provinces into historical boundaries (boundary=historical)