OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
138158089

This appears to be fantasy mapping - see osm.org/user_blocks/7274

73913288

Hello,
What actually is node/6758965639 ? I'm guessing it isn't a "basket of flammable stuff on a stick" (which some of man%20made=beacon?uselang=en-GB at least is).
Best Regards,
Andy

137316849

Hallo fkv,
Die goldene Regel von OSM lautet: Wenn Ihnen viele Leute sagen, dass Sie falsch liegen, dann liegen Sie wahrscheinlich falsch.
Hier deutet https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/1021250484 darauf hin, dass in diesem speziellen Argument niemand auf Ihrer Seite ist.
Wenn Sie immer noch der Meinung sind, dass Sie Recht haben, führen Sie die Diskussion bitte zu https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/at/59.
Mit freundlichen Grüßen,
Andy Townsend von der Datenarbeitsgruppe von OSM.

137316849

Hello fkv,
The golden rule of OSM is that if lots of people are telling you that you are wrong, you probably are.
Here https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/1021250484 suggests that there is no-one on your side in this particular argument.
If you _still_ think that you are correct, please take the discussion to https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/at/59 .
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, from OSM's Data Working Group.

138109479

Hello Andrew Saunders, and welcome to OSM.
I'm a bit surprised that this path is not signed as closed in any way, given that there was a previous discussion over at changeset/135290950 where some National Trust people said that they were trying to close it. You wouldn't happen to have taken any photos while you were there recently? I've asked the same question over on the NT changeset.
Best Regards,
Andy

127813200

For info, osm.org/user_blocks/7272 .

135509113

Thanks!

135290950

Oddly, someone thinks that this path is still open - perhaps it is worth commenting on changeset/138109479 ?
Also, photos would be great...

128609373

Cockup - My notes just say "post" for each. I've changed them.

138024427

For the avoidance of doubt, this is a revert to the state immediately before the edits - it does not mean that previous values were "correct". As an example, I'd expect that way/1184324514/history would have names in both Ukrainian (name:uk) and Russian (name:ru), and that the "name" tag would follow the rules set out in https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/w/images/d/d8/DisputedTerritoriesInformation.pdf .

138024427

See osm.org/user_blocks/7240 for why this data was reverted. See also https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/topic/100629/21 and the following comments.

132917774

Thanks!

85559544

Thanks

124283452

Thanks

133571789

Thanks!

135509113

Hello node/6800626687 has "wheelchair=yes;no" on it. If it's accessible from one side I'd have expected "yes"?
Best Regards,
Andy

85559544

Hello,
It looks like there's been a problem merging things into node/4735935534/history as it now has "wheelchair=no;yes".
Cheers,
Andy

133571789

Hello,
I was wondering how to interpret the "wheelchair" = "nolive_music=yes" tag on Upstairs @ Ronnie's here?
Cheers,
Andy

134428577

Hello,
I'm guessing that the wheelchair tag on way/1159243300 should perhaps be a width?
Regards,
Andy

119438253

Should the wheelchair tag on node/9649547673 perhaps be a source tag?