SK53's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 61995456 | I note that you've tagged a place as diet:vegan=yes and diet:vegtarian=no. As presumably any vegetarian can eat vegan food I don't think this is the best approach: it requires that anyone looking for vegetarian food has to examine both tags. This may work for your application, but may result in a large number of false negatives in other applications. |
|
| 39552016 | Is the Kingdom Hall in Liskeard really a Lutheran church. Seems a little unlikely in Cornwall. Kingdom Halls are usually Jehovahs Witness PoW. |
|
| 63997414 | Are you sure this is a Seventh Day Adventist Church? Usually Kingdom Hall signifies Jehovahs Witnesses. |
|
| 63860656 | I very much doubt that "Australie" is the normal description for the country, nor that a Kingdom Hall is a catholic church. The former should be addr:country=au, the latter is most likely denomination=jehovahs_witness |
|
| 67312777 | Hi & welcome to OpenStreetMap. I was wondering if the track you have added the horse & bicycle permissions too is a public bridleway? If it is the additional tag designation=public_bridleway is very useful. Also if it is a track it's entire length then the highway tag can be changed to track. There is a map made with OSM data specifically focussed on public rights of way. The area around Hodsock looks like this: https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#zoom=14&lat=53.36164&lon=-1.08023. Contrast that with around Gringley-on-the-Hill https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#zoom=14&lat=53.40398&lon=-0.89475. We had a day mapping footpaths around Gringley, but there's still loads of information (and paths) missing in this part of Notts. I'm Nottingham-based so I don't do much around here. Best wishes, Jerry aka SK53 |
|
| 67104475 | Some oneway tags missing I think on the ones you've added. Presumably a more recent version of OpenRoads than I had to hand. |
|
| 67015136 | Thanks for fixing this one |
|
| 22987128 | I presume use of landuse=village_green for woods in this changeset was an accident (e.g., by copying previous tags). I've corrected a few, but its quite likely I've missed some. |
|
| 17200805 | I'd be more persuaded that this is an OS error given that they also show it as a public road; it's not replicated onto the StreetView layers. |
|
| 17200805 | You added Bawburgh Road as a name to the track at way/232206196. This looks unlikely as it is not heading towards Bawburgh. Current public notices wrt compulsory purchase orders for the Hornsea 3 windfarm power cables at Algarsthorpe all mention Algarsthorpe as being situated to the N of Bawburgh Road. This image of the gate at the S end doesn't show any signs of it being named https://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/4858464. |
|
| 66451704 | Apologies then. I don't use it myself as I don't think its necessary. However it seems totally in contradiction to normal OSM practice of always using non-abbreviated names. |
|
| 66736699 | Many thanks for the link; I live quite near the other Moira (in Leics). You may not know but the OpenStreetMap Irish community have a couple of useful resources for local historians: old maps (mainly 1:25k maps made by the British Military Survey just before WWII by photo reducing old 6 inch maps http://maps.openstreetmap.ie/oocmaps.html). Also there is a website covering all Townlands in Ireland https://www.townlands.ie/down/moira/). Thanks also for highlighting missing baptist churches. I made a start up around Magherafelt & Cookstown, but got distracted by looking for fire stations too. |
|
| 66567103 | The Beeston unparished area clearly includes separate places Bramcote, Toton, Attenborough, Chilwell & Beeston itself. These are different places, they may have once been in the same Urban District in the past (But I think it was Beeston & Sandiacre). Making them all Beeston not only fails the test of what someone living there would say, but creates issues with, for starters, Meadow Lane, Attenborough and Meadow Lane, Beeston. |
|
| 66451704 | No, that's incorrect, you are misreading addr:state which refers solely to US States like Alaska. For addr:country you should use the full word. In practice I would recommend not adding addr:country as it can easily be inferred from the country geometry itself |
|
| 48730957 | Nope, they are different in that a beer garden is always an ancillary amenity of a pub, whereas amenity=biergarten implies that it's a pub of a particular kind. You can see that this causes issues on things like cycle.travel https://cycle.travel/map?lat=51.5613&lon=-0.9328&zoom=14 which was showing 2 pubs, when there is only one. I've reverted the edit. |
|
| 48730957 | Hm, have you visited the Rainbow Inn, did you find lots of young women in dindrl serving foaming Maß? I suspect not, this is an English beer garden not a German one, and we use a different tag. |
|
| 66645742 | https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=horses+head+gate+finial&qpvt=horses+head+gate+finial&FORM=IGRE and yes the man_made tag is mis-spelt |
|
| 66683087 | Long time ago, but does the bus loop past the Hotel Villa Margharita to drop skiers at the Vajolet 1 base station? Memory tells me it did back in 2007. Similarly think the bus goes to base of Col Rodella lift, and that there is a pick up at base of Pozza lift.I don't think you or anyone else has these. Unfortunately my visit was 2 years before I started with OSM. |
|
| 66736699 | No, I'm afraid that one looks like one of Bing's sources, and I doubt they'll respond as quickly. The OSM data should appear eventually in quite a range of maps & tools (Instagram, Snapchat, Facebook - but possibly not UK), but it can take a while I take a slight proprietary interest in the area I had the pleasure of staying overnight in Moira 15 months ago and did a bit of mapping before breakfast on a bright October morning (in the aftermath of Storm Ophelia), |
|
| 66736699 | Many thanks for adding the details of your church. I've made some minor alterations (mainly because the building was already mapped as a church & it was showing up twice). The significant things are: I added the car park; I changed "Baptist" to "baptist" (all tags other than names are in lower case); and I altered the service times to the general (but less-humanly readable) format. You can see here on OpenStreetBrowser how the data you added can already be used https://openstreetbrowser.org/#map=17/54.48035/-6.21902&categories=religion (I'm not sure if this does service times). This query shows other Baptist churches within about 25 miles which are already on OpenStreetMap: http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/FD8. I can see that there must be quite a few missing. I'll have a go at finding some more. |