SD Mapman's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 176235936 | There's no way to tell the actual name formatting from the ref though, each jurisdiction can be slightly different. Refs are essentially useless at this point with route relations too IMO. |
|
| 176235936 | So I've changed the name= tags back already from L62E to Rapid City just for reference. There is a stretch actually named Heartland Expressway in Hermosa, but otherwise the road names follow local county guidelines. |
|
| 179049032 | Note when I say the routes weren't good I meant that the relations were poor quality, was not discussing the physical routes themselves |
|
| 178882074 | Hello! Thanks for adding the public wildlife areas! We've typically been spelling them out instead of using abbreviations (e.g. "Game Production Area" instead of GPA), but otherwise good work! |
|
| 178541791 | I don't believe this actually exists, there's nothing out here to watch. If there is one out here I will be very surprised. |
|
| 175848878 | I'll clean it up, just as long as someone remembers to change it back this summer |
|
| 178432141 | I understand that, it's enough work just making sure the road names are correct around here. You've been doing good work overall, I never would have thought to update those developments to highway=living_street for example. |
|
| 166496569 | Are there actual plans to connect the N-66 gap in Louisville? Last time I was there the dead-end spur east of N-50 didn't look like it would ever be used as a state highway again. |
|
| 178432141 | So I've posed this to a thread on the OSM US slack (slack.openstreetmap.us), but it looks like stop signs can be mapped without using major/minor roads by putting the highway=stop at the stop line instead of the intersection. Would you be amenable to shifting to that methodology and the re-adjusting the highway classification to the way it was before (roughly)? |
|
| 178432141 | That makes sense on Medary, I'm fine with that.
Upgrade W. 16th Ave. S. between W. 8th St. S. and W. 20th St. S. to highway=secondary to link those two spurs. Change the CR 12 spur (and related county roads) out towards Sinai back to highway=tertiary to align with the rest of the state and their relative importance in the road network. |
|
| 178432141 | I changed West 8th South and West 20th South to highway=tertiary to get rid of secondary road spurs, those are generally to be avoided unless there's a good reason |
|
| 178432141 | Hello! So we don't get into an edit war here, why did you upgrade several county roads to highway=secondary? We haven't been using HFCS or other government classification systems in SD (they tend to over-classify things and then the map looks silly, I tried it in Spearfish), and generally most county roads are highway=tertiary with some exceptions. Also, I set Medary between 14 and the bypass to highway=primary because it's the "main street" for SDSU running right by the Campanile. Please let me know your thoughts. osm.wiki/South_Dakota/Highway_Classification
|
|
| 178434779 | Hello! "Future Road" is probably not the actual name of the proposed road here, I've removed the 'name' tag and changed this to highway=proposed |