OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
165341383

Then it should be tagged as
highway=speed_display

See:
highway=speed_display

164602609

Great.
And there are a lot of speed displays, that are incorrectly tagges as speed cameras.

165116258

Sorry,
I did not mean to discourage you.

164488787

Good point-

It is still useful if you recheck you own edits when you get back home and can use e.g., JOSM.

Maybe OsmAnd should at least add a fixme such nodes

164865403

Yes but
node/12750199438

Is not attached to the road and is not in an enforcement relation.

165409851

Yes it is OK to attach it to the road.
In the same changeset you have also attached traffic signals to the road, even though they are not actually placed in the middle of the road.

But if you do want to do attach speed cameras to the road, then you have to create an enforcement relation with the camera as device and a "to" and "from" points.

It the camera is in the middle of the road and the camera can check both directions, then you must create two enforcement relations.

If you just tag a speed camera as a node, that is not in an enforcement relation or attached to a road, then it is useless because data consumers, i.e., navigation software cannot know which roads are monitored.

165116258

node/12766235625

Is attached to way/36851805

Which is a forest.

It should be on the road, not the forest.

165116258

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164384191

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164565596

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165439543

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165433120

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165425028

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164002892

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165257767

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164541101

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165474327

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164982713

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

165481718

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera

164565905

Please attach speed cameras to the road.

Or create a maxspeed enforcement relation.

See:
highway=speed_camera