Mashin's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 84144593 | Path was added correctly.
|
|
| 84145657 | All good.
|
|
| 84089526 | Thanks for the info. I've updated the building footprint and details.
|
|
| 84089526 | You've added level and roof information for Helene Grant School building. This building sees to be rebuilt (see Mapbox Satellite, Esri imagery). Are those tags for the new or old building? |
|
| 83492721 | Hi, great work mapping those golf courses. Just one improvement: We place tag 'golf_course' only on the boundary of the whole course and not on the individual elements. |
|
| 83729177 | Hi, great work mapping those golf courses. Just one improvement: We place tag 'golf_course' only on the boundary of the whole course and not on the individual elements. See Thumble Brook Country Club just a bit to the west from this location. |
|
| 83729413 | Generally, can you explain your motivation behind all your changesets, where you deleted driveways and other service reads? As a beginner I recommend browsing through wiki.osm before deleting any structures, as you might not know the purpuse of those objects. |
|
| 81130909 | Yes particularly the earlier edits appear correct, but I don't think anybody has time to untangle the bad from good. I wrote to DWG, let's wait about their decision. |
|
| 81130909 | I think there is not much to discuss here, all changesets at least until #80982684 have to be reverted and user reported to DWG for blocking for vandalism. |
|
| 75612950 | 10+ hours of work and "Job appeared as rushed and without much care taken". Ouch. |
|
| 67647514 | Je to naozaj parkovisko, alebo parkovanie na ulici? parking:lane=* |
|
| 62892279 | Hi, I don't think that this is correct. From the areal imagery, it is obvious that the bridge is much longer. |
|
| 62374613 | 1) You added information about a company onto a line which represents Honeyspot Road. Businesses have to be represented either by a single node (at exact position = building) or in case a whole building belongs to the company, the tags are placed on building polygon itself. 2) You forgot to include tag that would identify what kind of business it is. In case of Kitchen Brains something like 'shop=electronics' would be appropriate. You can find all the information how to correctly edit OSM in wiki: wiki.openstreetmap.org or iD editor tutorial.
Edits with exactly the same mistake as yours appear in OSM about every 30 min and fixing them takes OSM community a lot of effort. Please, it would help if you could spread these information among your colleagues so their edits also follow OSM guidelines. |
|
| 62374613 | Hi, I reverted your edit.
|
|
| 62599391 | Hi and welcome to OSM!
1) No source for the data was specified
|
|
| 57922756 | From my point of view, since the two buildings are physically attached without any air gap, we should have them attached here as well, because we are mapping the reality. What I agree is controversial is the Quadrangle multipolygon and its validity.
Maybe I'll try to ask at OSM forum if anybody has a suggestion how to handle such cases. |
|
| 58014627 | Hi,
|
|
| 58014663 | Hi,
|
|
| 57922756 | The whole structure of the two Colleges is called Memorial Quadrangle and hence the multipolygon was created to avoid double naming.
And inner members sharing a line segment is OK (touching inner rings): osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon I am a little confused why two outer segment could not do the same. |
|
| 57922756 | What tool does report this as an error?
|