Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 129663436 | @Austrianton This won't do anything to Organic Maps / Maps.me uploaders. Better follow up on their Git issues to limit changeset extent. |
|
| 129631386 | OSM is about existing concepts in the most common use by the public. Use OpenHistoricalMap to reflect origins and evolutions. |
|
| 129631125 | Please don't mix up different levels. |
|
| 129630073 | Please don't attach unrelated features to other unrelated features especially roads. This doesn't represent reality, and makes editing difficult. |
|
| 129629728 | 4. Use OpenHistoricalMap to record the full history |
|
| 129629728 | 3. Descriptive changeset comments please |
|
| 129629728 | 1. Please don't remove other names. Move them to `alt_name=` etc.
|
|
| 129407577 | Please don't change `escalator=yes` to `highway=steps` + `conveying=yes` on features. It is used to mean whether it has escalator, not that it is an escalator. |
|
| 129373521 | Please don't add useless `name=` to carparks. This is misleading. |
|
| 129313117 | `highway=corridor` + `indoor=yes` is not valid. It is mixing archaic and the existing standard. Use `=footway` + `indoor=yes`. `layer=` should not be used either. |
|
| 129222544 | This is already included in `tunnel:name=`. It is not a major tunnel that qualifies as commonly known in `name=`. Similar to Airport Tn on Tung Wing Rd. |
|
| 129194870 | "If the medium of a pipeline you are tagging is not listed here, please choose a meaningful value at your own discretion." substance=* |
|
| 129194870 | Please don't remove information if you don't know what it is. The feedstock of this has significant naphtha to be reformed or cracked, resulting in a majority of the composition being hydrogen . Methane is only a little more than CO2. substance=gas is defined for exactly natural gas only. |
|
| 129031041 | Please don't remove the more correct `area:highway=traffic_island`. |
|
| 129004923 | Please don't use `=suburb` for this. At least you say it is a "village". |
|
| 128998937 | 1. Please note that precincts are already using `attraction=theme_area`, except East Coast Park. They are tentatively covered by Wan Chai Temporary Promenade.
|
|
| 128966428 | Please don't remove the `highway=pedestrian`. It is used for both. Or the `leisure=track` can be moved sideways. |
|
| 128892340 | "Site" is a site, so should use `addr:plot=` (tentatively). `addr:city_block=` (tentatively, to avoid confusion with `addr:block=` since building block number is a common concept in HK) is used for planning areas and subareas. |
|
| 128766350 | 1. Please don't merge sections mindlessly. They have different attributes.
|
|
| 128757402 | This Maps.me changeset needs to have the `name=` removed (is personal itenary), and their existence verified (some may be valid features. |