OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
119961084

Please don't open new accounts to fuel an edit war.

119960786

1. Please don't use changeset comments as a venue of discussion. https://discord.gg/P8fxC98
2. Please don't add your personal comments to map data. This is vandalism.

119965327

Please don't copy other's changeset comment without understanding it. Most are already changed to `old_name=`, contrary to what you are doing here.

119965327

If the name is wrong, change it. Don't delete the thing. It still represent something in reality.

119985036

3. Also you have not handled the different theme areas here.

119985036

3. You need to respect One Feature One Object. You should not break up a facility or area by when it opens. Sub-areas should be used.

119985036

1. I don't you commenting at me first before reverting. Do you know how it's done
2. Please don't confuse Expo Promenade and Golden Bauhinia Square. If you have a better idea of their extent, change it.
3. What is the purpose of breaking the `=multipolygon` up?

119929950

Please don't upload your personal test data. This is vandalism.

119884648

Please don't add descriptor labels. This is not a printed map. `name=` is for proper names only. Think of it as what is likely to be after opening. Use `description:zh=` otherwise.

119864590

See way/875635209

119864590

Please don't move to historic concepts or locations. This is reflecting the existing concept of the area.

N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` are the existing common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Use `old_name=` as needed, which says it's the original, not whether something is correct or wrong. Put historic names and locations in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate. Respect the One Feature, One Object rule, not mixing features up.

119865673

Although this part here might be for the bridge.

119865673

This is actually correct. There will be a triangular protrusion into water.
Recently there was a complaint about a organized editing team shrinking buildings constructed over water to within land wrongly in an international community, so I hope everyone can be more cautious before doing so.

119866740

If the name is wrong, remove the name only. Don't delete it. It still represents something in reality.

119841126

Changing `=bus` to `=bicycle` doesn't make sense.

119845204

This was already corrected to `old_name=`

119845204

Please don't delete it directly. It still represent something that exists in reality. If the name is wrong, remove that only.

119845666

1. Please don't change according to your own preference
2. Descriptive changeset comments please/

119823158

Not to mention the changeset comment.

119823158

Would be very bad if a new acc is opened to do this.