Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 142621174 | 2. `=priority_road` refers to `priority_road=yes` diamond signs in Europe. That's not used in HK. |
|
| 142621174 | `parking:*:restriction:reason=driveway` is used for `=service` roads. There is clearly none here. |
|
| 156237508 | `substation=` `=distribution` is for larger district level ones. `=minor_distribution` should be used for buildings and sites. |
|
| 157190759 | 2. Please don't move `barrier=` to intersecting points between `highway=` . This is invalid. |
|
| 157190759 | Please don't disconnect true `=pedestrian` from roads. They can physically accommodate cars. |
|
| 157191372 | 1. Please don't delete linear `highway=` when creating `highway=` + `area=yes` . They are needed for routing.
|
|
| 157083112 | 1. Please re-read guidelines
|
|
| 157162572 | Don't upload personal edits to a live public database. This is vandalism. |
|
| 157093615 | Please see previous |
|
| 157083112 | As shown by the Olympic Ave example, PWP item titles don't work either. 2HL covers the entire batch. Now you have to use the contract name, or basically anything people want. This is fine when creating a printed map on paper yourself for labeling. But OSM is a digital map database. It doesn't need "(WIP 2024)" etc. It needs some standards that can be followed. |
|
| 157083112 | https://www.legco.gov.hk/yr2023/english/fc/pwsc/papers/pwsc20230208pwsc-12-1-e.pdf |
|
| 157083112 | It has been dubbed "the Olympic Avenue site". Clearly the site is called Olympic Ave. I will only align with other sites here. |
|
| 157083112 | You are simply setting up a slippery slope for others to change into arbitary titles. This has already happened before with Kai Tak site numbers, and land lot numbers. |
|
| 157083112 | That's what `description=` is for. Adding such such info to `name=` based on rendering concerns violates 2 good practice. |
|
| 157083112 | https://www.districtcouncils.gov.hk/kwt/doc/2020_2023/en/dc_meetings_doc/21704/21_D_2022.pdf
|
|
| 157083112 | No offense to others who did their part, but for example it would be more ridiculous to have `name=重置駿業街遊樂場設施至康寧道公園及牛頭角配水庫 Reprovisioning of Tsun Yip Street Playground facilities to Hong Ning Road Park and Ngau Tau Kok Fresh Water Service Reservoir` way/121158738 |
|
| 157083112 | https://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/en/business-partnerships/resources/information-platform-non-insert-recyclable/location-plan-of-active-sites/index.html
|
|
| 157083112 | Can you please check the dictionary for the meaning of proper names?
|
|
| 157083112 | 1. `description:zh=` has already been used here |
|
| 157083112 | `name=` should be for proper names only, similar to what might be used after opening. Don't direct copy descriptor labels coined by others, or the entire project heading. |