OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
156717555

Please don't remove the `=waste_transfer_station`

156671062

I believe this is still the name as shown on maps. So the ground truth principle could be applied.

156671062

The `name=` of a `building=` should refer to what it is, not what it's functioning. Hung Hom Station is the whole complex. Exit C concourse is still correct.

156637308

Please understand that `=unclassified` means a minor road at the lowest level that has collector & distributor functions according to UK classification. `=residential` should be used for local streets.

156528395

Please don't delete other objects without understanding what they are. Don't blindly follow warnings and suggestions.

156421969

Please check again. This is a `building:part=` . There is already a `building=` here.

156395488

Please check carefully, and don't add duplicate `=reservoir_covered`

156395199

2. Please don't remove `building=` . That's a different aspect.

156395199

Please don't remove "Hong Kong Waterworks". That's signposted.

156388898

Please don't do such fiddling test en masse. You forgot to add back `pipeline=substation` here.

156394136

Please don't change `=service` to `=industrial`

156385406

Reminder: `name=` and `place=` are the existing common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names and locations in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong).

156379852

1. Please don't remove the address. It is still assigned.
2. Please don't use these project names directly. `name=` should be a proper name, that's similar to what will be used when it opens.

156303474

I meant it's better to avoid adding `crossing:island=` `=yes` or `=no` for divided roads entirely. Both aren't clear.

155676983

It's not "ideally". It's required.
Only Denmark has discussed it. You can't re-do it worldwide unless you discuss it.

155463565

!. As I warned you, please don't delete something when you haven't fully replaced them.
2. Please don't delete `landuse=cemetery` when you add `cemetery=grave` . They are different aspects.

156249387

2. You need to be especially careful with flyovers for `=street` . Many of them don't have gazetted street names. They won't have street name signs. The street name signs will appear for ground level only. I believe this is the case for Kowlooon City Roundabout. They only have `name=` for routing or common sense (which can still be doubted as there other possible names for them), or to improperly fix warnings. So they might only be included in the `=highway` .

155676983

"undiscussed" is referring to "undiscussed mechanical edits". It needs to be discussed beforehand, not afterwards.

155676983

Where else has it been discussed, and what's the "consensus"? No one here agreed with you.

156262744

Please avoid adding `crossing:island=no` for divided roads which has been split. The status of them is unclear.