Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 136596023 | Would be better to put KMB's long names with the location prefix in `official_name=` (reserving `short_name=` for estate names and such) , as `name=` is the common name. As a side benefit, renderers and applications can group the same name stop from Citybus using the same `name=`. |
|
| 136548277 | Please don't delete a road with `lanes=` without adding that back. |
|
| 136507610 | Please transfer all the tags if you ever want to delete something... |
|
| 136502769 | This causes a duplicate. Not the entire area is used for that either. |
|
| 136498624 | Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=`, which is for proper names only. Use `description:*=` . |
|
| 136499835 | Please don't change `=traffic_signals` to `=uncontrolled` |
|
| 136408778 | No idea why you would draw this on an uninhabited area. |
|
| 136408778 | This is obviously too small for a `=suburb`. Please don't draw areas for `place=`. This duplicates the point, and is inapplicable for `place=` being a vague concept. This is not done locally. |
|
| 136322589 | You didn't add back the crosswalk and sidewalk at Sai Yeung Choi St. |
|
| 135999214 | This is mentioned in osm.wiki/Guidelines_for_pedestrian_navigation#Ways_inside_buildings although it has other problems. Also used in osm.wiki/MENTZ_GmbH/Modellierungsvorschläge_Indoor and osm.wiki/France/Transilien/Hackcess in some extent. |
|
| 135999214 | `=footway` + `indoor=yes` should be used instead of `=corridor` for consistency with `=steps` + `indoor=yes`, and perhaps other vehicular roads. https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=footway#combinations is more numerous at 50k than the 40k https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=corridor |
|
| 135923227 | Please don't draw areas attached on roads. It doesn't represent reality, and make editing difficult. Draw them along the sidewalk physically. |
|
| 135762439 | Please don't remove `landuse=highway`. It's for the land corridor. |
|
| 135532728 | 2 roads on the west will continue to exist in the new PTI. |
|
| 135532728 | Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=`, which is for proper names only. Use `description=`. |
|
| 135489189 | 1. `=permissive` should not be added as that's for more "private" ones that the management may forbid the public from using freely at any time.
|
|
| 135489575 | Please only add descriptor labels in `description:zh=`. It is also unnecessary and unworkable to describe what each staircase connects between. |
|
| 135491228 | Please don't add descriptor labels as `name=` . It is for proper names only. |
|
| 135365446 | Please don't delete the area as it will be converted to other uses later. |
|
| 135273400 | The editing software is what's incorrect. `zh` means "Chinese" as a macrolanguage in the original standard, more precisely Sinitic languages. (In the newest standard, `zhx` is used for this language family) Mandarin itself is assigned `cmn`.
|