OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
70688662

Please don't delete objects en masse. Use JOSM's Replace Geometry to do this.

70680529

Please learn how to tag names,

70670861

"marked" crossings would be ambiguous as well here.

70670861

Ie `crossing:zebra=yes` means there is zebra marking here. This is to not confuse mappers with the tags.

70670861

(In Hong Kong `crossing=zebra` and the previous `crossing_ref=zebra` documents zebra crossings which has clear facility standards and pedestrian priority)

70670861

It is most likely an `uncontrolled` but with zebra markings.

70670861

Hi. `crossing_ref=zebra` is inappropriate here. I used `crossing:zebra` as the zebra stripe markings doesn't reflect its status as a zebra crossing.

70644727

@hd_scania He has a point on changing the guideline. That can be discussed further. For now I have already put a `motorroad=yes` and `motorroad:tunnel=yes` as a stopgap.

70644727

1. Hong Kong doesn't use "快速公路" this way. This is a wrong interpretation, based on your misuse of "高速公路" here. .
2. I do not consider Lung Cheung Road as an "expressway". There are direct bus stop access. It's merely a fully grade separated limited access trunk road, not fully controlled-access.

70645984

4. Stop ruining names. You aren't following the convention.

70645984

1. Please comment on other's changeset instead of treating your changeset as an annoucement everyone should read.
2. Hong Kong doesn't use "快速公路" this way. This is a wrong interpretation, based on your misuse of "高速公路" here. .
3. I do not consider Lung Cheung Road as an "expressway". There are direct bus stop access. It's merely a fully grade separated limited access road, not fully controlled-access.

70626397

To supplement, only CtB-NWFB omits that.

70626397

This is incorrect. The `bus_station`'s name includes "Bus Terminus", as there are also PTIs and bus interchanges in HK

70617011

5. With `trunk` it also failed to convey the motorway-like restrictions. At minimal `motorroad` is needed.

70614948

You need to add in `turn:lanes` and `change:lanes` for your deletion to function.

70617011

3. The extent of Tunnel Area is not known yet. It would more likely begin south of Ping Yeung Interchange. Unless the entire Highway is designated a Control Zone, it would not be meaningful to classified the full length into one type.
4. `trunk` is for roads belong to a Strategic Route. Unlike Tuen Mun -- Chap Lap Kok Link in Route 10, in the short term it is unlikely to be designated into any Route. `primary` would be misleading.

70617011

1. Please read osm.wiki/WikiProject_Hong_Kong/Transport/Road. In lieu of a better tag, it's opted for `motorway` for Tunnel Area. While I am going to propose a change related to `motorroad`, it's better to keep the status quo unchanged.
2. An unfinished road would of course not be gazetted yet, for that matter.

70464297

Please don't delete a way with 14 versions and recreate it next time.

70403793

>*Deprecated `construction=yes`

70403793

changeset/70405586