Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 142682075 | `building=apartments` is an apartment building. However `residential=apartments` is an apartment complex that's basically defined for multi-building housing estates. |
|
| 142682075 | It is obviously meant for `landuse=residential` + `residential=` .... |
|
| 142682075 | Why changing `=apartments` to `=residential` ? |
|
| 142601985 | Please don't draw vehicle path curves. This is unrealistic, and needless complication. Follow the kerb line only. |
|
| 142587270 | Please don't use `residential=apartments` for single buildings. It's defined for housing estates. |
|
| 142579558 | Please don't use `=construction`. The road is built, and not destroyed. |
|
| 131001893 | 2. Please don't add `wiki*=` to multiple objects. It should be unique. |
|
| 131001893 | Please don't add `shop=mall` to individual buildings of a mall. This is duplicating. |
|
| 142074857 | I'm not "telling you what to do". It's a notification that you can ignore if you wish. Don't complain when I change it back that is. |
|
| 142459634 | Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=` . It is for proper names only. Use `description:en=` + `description:zh=` . |
|
| 142436390 | `bridge=covered` could be used. It means fully enclosed. The namesake type can be indicated with `bridge:material=wood` . Eg `=viaduct` doesn't have to be steel or concrete. As long as it has many spans.
|
|
| 142074857 | Yes there is. `substance=` is widely used and supported. Using `pumping_station=` prevents it from being used for other purposes.
|
|
| 142074857 | I haven't added `pipeline=substation` . `substance=` is used with it. |
|
| 142415759 | Please use `abandoned:highway=path` to avoid others re-adding it again. It's still shown on other maps. |
|
| 142074857 | Originally it is worded as "It is better to use the name of the substance transported with the key substance=*" osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Tag:man_made=pumping_station&oldid=1881857 |
|
| 142074857 | `substance=` is general standard used for all features, and "approved" formally. There are only 3.5k `pumping_station=` . |
|
| 142074857 | The wiki is not a bible. It's obviously self-conflicting to say those are "The activity in which the station is involved". What is the `=water` or `=gas` used for? Drinking and cooking, electricity generation, or heating? "The actual substance processed" is a better definition, and that's using `substance=` already. |
|
| 142074857 | Please don't change `substance=` to `pumping_station=` . This is a meaningless duplicate. man_made=pumping_station#Tags_used_in_combination |
|
| 142305475 | `landuse=` is about the use. Not zoning or laws. |
|
| 142339599 | `=headrace` is used for hydropower only. It's not applicable. |