OpenStreetMap
Gregory Peony's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 166859427 | You correctly modified the highway to avoid data overlap.
|
|
| 166859427 | Welcome to OSM! The vast majority of footprints you mapped here represent buildings in the imagery. The imagery allows for these footprints to be more accurate. Please map individual buildings without collecting multiple nearby buildings into a single object. Zoom in so that you can see the outline of the roofs and look for the gaps between the buildings or different roof colors to help determine where one building ends and another begins. When mapping buildings, please trace the shape accurately. Zoom in so that you can see the outline of the building and mark the corners carefully. Don't include the building's shadow. Please do not snap the corners of the buildings to other buildings or features such as roads and paths. In the iD Editor, hold down the `Alt` key to keep nodes from snapping to other objects and accidentally connecting. This [video about connected nodes](https://youtu.be/ltn1VOiq5_0) has more information and a guide.
|
|
| 164090438 | You did well to delete invalid footprints that enveloped multiple buildings, but the footprints you added could have been more accurate and squared (q). Please keep this feedback in mind when contributing in future. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
|
| 164177642 | You made a good decision to not square all of the corners of the SE footprint.
|
|
| 164177990 | You correctly identified buildings in imagery. Some of these footprints are oversized. You correctly identified the shape of the L shaped building.
|
|
| 164180112 | Most buildings here are valid but inaccurate becasue they are oversized and have not been squared.
|
|
| 164324998 | scratch last. Hold ctrl. to prevent the creation of common nodes.
|
|
| 164324998 | Hold alt to prevent the creation of shared nodes.
|
|
| 164325143 | You identified buildings in imagery. You deleted valid footprints which could have been modified instead.
|
|
| 166858331 | some of these footprints are well mapped when looking at bing which was used to map them. I recommend aligningit to ESRI so that features are properly aligned. See my project comment.
|
|
| 166859574 | The footprints I flagged are oversized and sometimes envelope multiple buildings. Map footprints slightly smaller than the roof since it likely overhangs the walls somewhat.
|
|
| 166860909 | It's good that you're using multiple sources to aid your interpretation; I recommend that you offset the imagery source before digitising to keep features correctly aligned with one another. In this case the buildings are several meters West of where they should be if they were aligned to ESRI as per the instructions.
|
|
| 168402655 | The buildings you added here are likley temporal yurts and should not be mapped as they will likely not be there for long. Please keep this feedback in mind when contributing in future. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
|
| 159484189 | You correctly differentiated between round and square buildings. The round building has been appropriately rounded but the square buildings have not been squared and tend to have odd shapes. I recommend watching the missing maps beginer mistakes youtube videos.
|
|
| 166860694 | The footprint I flagged should be L shaped.
|
|
| 166860560 | You identified buildings in the imagery and appropriately squared them. The ones I flagged are oversized and sometimes envelope multiple buildings.
|
|
| 166858558 | I do not believe the features I tagged represent buildings visible in imagery but rather yards or parts of them.
|
|
| 166858121 | The geometry of the footpritns you mapped here is generally good, though could be a more accurate at times. Check Changeset: 168817115 to see how I mapped some of these features. Keep in mind that pitched roofs tend to overhang the walls of buildings and some include the building's shadow in the footprint. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
|
| 166863202 | The Western Footprint is well mapped more like this in future please. Check Changeset: 168816457 to see how I mapped these buildings.
|
|
| 166859212 | These footprints are valid but inaccurate. Take care to not include the shadow of a building in its footprint as that makes it oversized. The footprint you deleted is also valid.
|