OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
126523495

Sorry for the delay in replying. Think that quote in the editor help is shortened from here: bicycle=yes - which says it is "applied where cycling is legal" - so not the case for this footway.
I understand why you would want to use it (I'd probably also use it as a shortcut) however we need to map what is on the ground, in terms of actual legal access restrictions.
Routers such as cycle.travel and Komoot can already direct you to dismount/push in some sections, so maybe suggest that to the developer of the app you are using? Or ask the council to make it shared use? :)

126647169

Ok - but we cannot use Google Street View as a source to add things to OSM, so you should wait until you've surveyed or have another acceptable source before adding.
In case you're not aware Bing Streetside imagery (and Mapillary) is available in the editor for use in OSM, so you might be able to confirm markers using it - for example: https://www.bing.com/maps?osid=4baff3d5-2b8e-40ae-a48d-cac0101e2c7f&cp=56.216443~-2.887277&lvl=19&dir=345.34268&pi=-9.232215&style=x&mo=z.0&v=2&sV=2&form=S00027

126815082

Not on the pavement you added, the shared use bit stops here: https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=918575715621153 - there's no signs between there and the roundabout, plus Sustrans/Fife Council have it mapped as an on-road section. Unless I've missed someone on mapillary?

126889003

Please don't connect the landuse to the roads.

126815082

What is the evidence that these footways are shared use?

126513966

Hi, welcome to OSM and thanks for adding these details. I've fixed the "Sat"->"Sa" here. If you are doing surveys it's worth turning on the map notes layer osm.org/#map=14/56.3966/-3.4446&layers=N to see if there's any notes you can help resolve in Perth.

126523495

This was originally a footway - what was the reason for adding bicycle=yes, is there a blue sign making this shared use?

126739349

The steps and path are marked as access=no way/552866977 so not sure why you have added access=yes to the gate?

126647169

You had tagged this as a building so I've fixed it.
Also, what is your source for these pipeline markers you've been adding?

124764471

*why you have done that

124764471

Thanks for changing it back and keeping it consistent :)

As for the path connected to Ashley Road, @Alopix my original question is because you added bicycle access, however I'm wondering you have done that?

126334644

Thanks but all of these places are already mapped, e.g. way/100913753 so I've reverted the changeset.

119264096

way/1047629391 is this actually a school (ie primary/secondary) or is it more like a nursery/kindergarten/childcare?

123937431

Hi, did you mean to set this road as ford=yes? way/120152285/history

125117737

Hi, is this unconnected stile a duplicate of the one you added? node/5611753886

125128078

Please don't go around blindly updating brands by just pressing a button in iD - there are no Lloyds Bank branches in Scotland.

124116013

Well railway platforms in OSM are tagged with a ref so data consumers and renderers can use that combination to display "Platform x" on the map if they wish.
Just like how we don't tag names on a motorway in OSM yet the map shows M8 for example.

124116013

This has been reverted. The platforms do not have names.

124558958

Reverted this changeset and others in Edinburgh

125948703

Just FYI, if you do ctrl+shift+B in iD it brings up the background panel which usually has the date of the imagery - Bing says Dec 2021
(saw your tweet!)