OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
53029336

Hi again!
Please can you add some details where this parking lot is located and who can use it? Sat images don't show it.
See amenity=parking

53029304

Hi and welcome to OSM!
You tried to map something here but I fear I don't understand what it is. Please check the wiki about highways: highway=*

51979047

Hi!
I see that you started to fix these strange numbers. I also want to do that. What do you think that addr:housenumber=KS (or ks / Ks etc) means?
Unfortunately most numbers don't have a valid addr:street tag. Do you see a good reason for this?

45017983

I wonder if the primary road is in a tunnel?
way/464661119
It seems to go straight through buildings with both lanes.

53017134

Hi!
I've noticed this change because you use highway=crossing on some ways. This tag should only be used for the node shared by the major road and the footway. The way itself should be tagged highway=footway + footway=crossing.
See also highway=crossing
You should also connect these footways with the minor roads as the major is a trunk road which doesn't allow pedestrians. An alternative would be that there is a sidewalk next to the trunk road, in this case you may map that with sidewalk=right and only tag the nodes.
I did not correct it myself because sat images don't show where the footways lead to.

53013443

Hi!
Please review the ways with highway=bus_guideway like this one:
way/533172280
This is a very special typo of road, see highway=bus_guideway
Mapbox shows ways with road markings,this would not be needed with a guided way.

53021196

Hi!
Please check my corrections for roads where you entered the name with the highway key:
changeset/53030610

52988147

I learned now that you work for the "AI-Assisted Road Tracing" project. My understanding of the wiki page is that you should not tag each way with source=* and import=yes but instead use these tags for the changeset. I think this would be much better.

50142974

OK, maybe my understanding is too poor. I've asked the UK forum for help
https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=668571#p668571

51252009

Hi and welcome to OSM!
You changed a rather large area from landuse=residential to amenity=marketplace
building=yes
name=Ranen Market Centre
way/455165941
I've reverted this change, please draw a new way for the marketplace.

50142974

Since you don't seem to use one of the common prefixes to express this
what about historic=way? This is used far more often than highway=historic.

52992987

OK, that is understood. Question is what tag can be used to express this. Since there is no highway on the southern part of the bridge I wonder why you don't simple remove the highway tag.

52992987

Hi!
What means highway="path possible, but extremely dangerous" ?
way/205949005
I assume you wanted to add this as a note?

50267242

Hi!
Please check:
What is meant with import=yes used on some new ways?
They all have the tags import=yes + source=digitalglobe so it doesn't seem to be an import as described here:
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

52988147

Hi!
Please review 5 roads with highway=R
in this changeset. I assume you meant residential?
Why do you add import=yes to these ways? If these ways are from an import, you should mention the source of this import instead or additional to Digital Globe. In this case I assume you just use copy+paste for new ways like this
way/532981872

50142974

OK, so you think the owners still use if for walking? In that case it would be a highway=footway + access=private
or maybe hw=path, right?

37202447

Siehe changeset/52982507
Statt hw=razed könnte man auch historic=way in betracht ziehen. Die Relation
way/397631667
ist auch nicht wirklich korrekt, ist ja mehr 'ne Sammelrelation als 'ne route.

50142974

Hi!
What does the rarely used highway=historic mean on these two ways?
way/506142967
way/506142970
Maybe you want to express that the ways are no longer usable?
Please check osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix for better tags.
Or maybe it is a historic=way ?

52858634

Yes, since the sidewalk is not mapped as a separate way I think you just have to add the nodes as you suggested.

29931144

OK, thanks, Will have a look at it later.