OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
175312248

Changeset reverted because it added a duplicate cycleway alongside the existing highway=road way named "Downtown Greenway" that could've been retagged as highway=cycleway and left way overlaps where a newly mapped bridge and cycleway was mapped and connected on the existing bridge (way/100025376, way/1454900578, way/1454900574, and way/1454900577).

changeset/176928680

FacilMap link of this changeset: https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20175312248

144952995

Please take the time to leave better changeset comments. What did you change and why? "NA" is not considered a good changeset comment.
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

144309762

If you can take the time to leave better changeset comments (what did you change and why), then it will be easier for other mappers to understand what you have done and why. "NA" is not considered a good changeset comment.
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Could you explain what you did in this changeset (I'm not trying to say it's bad. Mostly just curious)? Thanks.

176863332

The road serving the church is not a dual carriageway. You mapped another road right next to the one you mapped in your previous changeset: way/1464365981 and way/1464365982

176744989

*Please disregard my previous comment. I was meant to put the comment in the next changeset.*

162596452

Related changesets:
changeset/162366141
changeset/162366017
changeset/162365570

FacilMap links of this and related changesets:
https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20162596452
https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20162366141
https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20162366017
https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20162365570

162365570

Please see more of my comments in changeset/162596452

162366017

Please see more of my comments in changeset/162596452

162366141

Please see more of my comments in changeset/162596452

176744989

The road serving the church is not a dual carriageway. You mapped another road right next to the one you mapped in your previous changeset: way/1464365981 and way/1464365982

165961724

Changeset partially reverted because it inexplicably deleted a parking area that I can personally verify still exists.
changeset/176892150

176769091

***Corrected Comment***:
Also, when other mappers comment on any of your changesets, you must almost always respond, even if that answer might be "I don't know" or you fixed the issues yourself. Public communication between mappers is crucial to building trust. Edits of people who never respond may be treated as less trustworthy. Unresponsive users who continue questionable edits despite being contacted multiple times first get a warning (so-called 0-day block), then progressively longer blocks on their account.
osm.wiki/Changeset#Someone_commented_on_my_changeset,_what_should_I_do

175312248

Hello Gborobiker, welcome to OSM! I see that you requested a review of this changeset. Unfortuanately, this changeset added a duplicate cycleway along the existing highway=road way named "Downtown Greenway" that could've been retagged as a cycleway. Since the West Side of the Downtown Greenway was recently completed, you could have retagged the existing road on the recently completed trail (former abandoned rail line) as highway=cycleway instead of mapping a new cycleway alongside the existing highway=road way named "Downtown Greenway".

176805088

Whoops! Looks like I made a mistake here. :) I went ahead and retagged the stop sign nodes on the painted stop lines as road_marking=stop_line + stroke=solid and properly tagged the intersection node as highway=stop + direction=both. changeset/176886412
I had been tagging intersection nodes as stop signs where there is an all-way stop, but for this all-way stop in front of University Mall, I added the stop sign nodes on the stop lines instead of a stop sign node on the intersection node due to me failing to exercise diligence when mapping the stop signs. In the future, I will be sure to be more diligent when adding or modifying map features (such as stop signs).

176769091

In your future edits on OSM, please comply with OSM good practices.
osm.wiki/Good_practice

168963074

Changeset reverted because it unnecessarily changed valid service roads and driveways around schools to unclassified roads.
changeset/176842322

168961916

Changeset reverted because it unnecessarily changed valid service roads and driveways around schools to unclassified roads.
changeset/176842322

174510040

Changeset reverted
changeset/176840793

165961724

You can see the FacilMap link of this changeset and you'll see that you deleted a valid parking area that I can verify still exists here: https://facilmap.org/#q=changeset%20165961724

165961724

Can you explain why you deleted a valid parking area in this changeset? I can personally verify that the parking area still exists here. way/1108010434