OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
81542888

Hi
It becomes "complex" if tags are duplicated in irrelevant locations.
You added a stop area relation. Therefore any routing software will be able to find the ref:crs on the station node.
Adding duplicating data only leads to confusion & errors.
One station = one station code.

Please add railway=stop + the relevant NapTAN stop position codes to enable accurate routing.

72281378

Those are all railway codes. Why have you added it to a bus stop (that's nowhere near a railway)? Are you reading old data for the station on the former line that is now a busway?

72281378

Hi again
Where did you obtain the ref:crs tag from?

72281378

Hi
Where did you obtain the ref:CRS tag from?

72281378

Hi
What has Network Rail data to do with bus stops?

56769615

Great, thanks.

28910229

Has this building been removed?

81542888

Adding superfluous ref:crs tags "skews the data" . In this instance - for the router.

80578022

Cheers

79369743

Hi
Amenity=park is incorrect. but what is it?

78338301

highway=ford is deprecated for ford=yes

node/7052051329

80578022

node/7187240576#map=18/54.06513/-2.16555

highway=ford is deprecated for ford=yes

77371109

Ta

81051746

Great. Thanks

81542888

osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer

81542888

Hi
I think railway=stop + the relevant NapTAN stop position code is what should be added.
osm.wiki/NaPTAN#NaPTAN

The correct term is tagging *incorrectly* to suit the renderer. Positioning nodes so valid data can display isn't incorrect.See village place names as an example. It's a bit awkward because the platforms are askew but somewhere half way between the two on railway land is fine for the station node.

81051746

Hi
As you've deleted the bridge over Kingham Station how do passengers get to the opposite platform?
Are you sure the footpath here no longer exists?osm.org/go/eunyG79Mw--?m=

81562556

Hi Mark
Why have you deleted this landuse polygon?
If it's owned/used by a railway company for 'railway' purposes then it's a valid addition to OSM.
if the area demarcated is inaccurate then it should be amended, not removed.

81542888

Hi Brian
There should only be one ref:crs per station & it should be on the railway=station node.
It's best to position that node away from the station building to allow its name & other facilities to render & display.

73960971

If you spot any of my errors, let me know & I'll fix them.

The node in the channel is still there.