OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
139768242

Hi
FYI All railway=stations are already mapped.

way/191154264

139761203

Hi
FYI All railway=stations already mapped.
way/492669338

139705263

Hi
1. Please try & avoid connecting physical objects to boundaries which in this case is a separate entity.
node/11104712574#map=19/51.39926/-2.37140

2. For reference/validation purposes it's probably best to put edits as separated as Bath & Scotland into two different changesets.

(wait a while for it to load)
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=139705263

139519215

Hi
Please don't add tags to ways when they're already included in the relation.
way/258215398#map=14/51.3745/-2.3079

139426599

As you've not replied, but continued editing I assume you don't have a relevant argument. Please refrain from making unnecessary changes. If you're using a bot/routine to auto check, please amend your code to avoid repetition.

139426599

I can see the amendments you made. I wish to know the reasons you made them.

139426599

So my original question remains unanswered.

139426599

What was the ref of the "one node section of Way: Frome Road (4411939)"?

Struggling to see where "duplicate section of highway." were. Please indicate the relevant refs.

139446002

It's a two-lane road with a dashed line. As far as I'm aware there's no rules disallowing it.

OSM is a do-ocricy. Contributors take responsibility & correct their own mistakes.

139405343

Hi
Welcome to OSM.

Please don't attach objects, in this instance a gate, to boundaries.
If possible, add the fence/wall etc & attach it to that.

Also, if you're amending objects in a small area it's preferable to perform the actions in one changeset, instead of one object per changeset.

139426599

Hi
Could you clarify your amendments.

139446002

Hi
Could you clarify the purpose of this relation?
relation/16159571

traffic_signals:direction tags aren't required on one-way streets

139263721

Hi
Was there a specific reason you deleted this way & removed its history?
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/51293007

139218864

Hi
All UK railway stations are mapped as nodes, to allow central accurate location.
Railway=stations as an area are generally inaccurate. They overlap rail tracks which aren't publicly accessible. How far beyond the platforms should they be mapped?

it's beneficial to map areas as landuse=railway (OSM-Carto render it the same colour as railway=station polygons)

137367001

Hi
All UK railway stations are mapped as nodes, to allow central accurate location.
Railway=stations as an area are generally inaccurate. They overlap rail tracks which aren't publicly accessible. How far beyond the platforms should they be mapped?

it's beneficial to map areas as landuse=railway (OSM-Carto render it the same colour as railway=station polygons)

137892879

Please refrain from adding erroneous tags to PROWs

138886200

Hi
There's no requirement for highway tags on platforms as their sole purpose is for people to walk on them. Routers should be able to manage them without the tag.

way/150691065#map=18/56.70252/-3.73472

138420048

Which wiki page?
Routers can handle platforms in the same way they handle highway=pedestrian

138420048

Hi
There's no requirement for highway tags on platforms as their sole purpose is for people to walk on them. Routers should be able to manage them without the tag.

138305209

Hi
Probably best it you leave the reversal to me. I can do it in one go.

If you tell me what you're trying to achieve with Trans Euro Trail I may be able to help.