OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
138014381

Do not add things that don't exist. Removed and reverted.

138013864

Do not add things incorrectly. This is just a driveway, not a cartpath, and definitely not with that name.

138014329

way/1186449218

Is not a golf hole....

137967523

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property

137964748

I don't think it is the first time this user has done it. Also, their changesets of "yes" are not very helpful. I've commented on their changesets previously, to no avail.

137737955

As I have mentioned before, please use more detailed changeset comments. Instead of "Yes", can you put what you changed and why?

More details on good changeset comments can be found here:
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments#:~:text=A%20good%20changeset%20comment%20should,have%20edited%20on%20the%20map.

134284770

Sounds like the on/off ramps might be open?

https://www.news.iowadot.gov/newsandinfo/2023/03/bridge-replacement-on-polk-county-road-f-22ne-126th-avenue-over-i-35-begins-wednesday-march-29.html#:~:text=Drivers%20may%20find%20that%20the%20north%2D%20and%20southbound%20I%2D35%20ramps%20at%20Exit%2096%20may%20be%20open%20at%20times%20depending%20on%20the%20work%20taking%20place.

137961436

The changeset was reverted since these paths/trails are visible from aerial imagery. Access tags should be used instead rather than just deleting them.

Please do not delete trails/paths just because they are on private property.

For more on why these should be mapped, read here:
osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t

changeset/137967523

137900656

What exactly are you testing?

137707663

Please do not "lollipop" areas. Specifically, you are adding in little areas to punch a hole, rather than using a multirelation if you must. I've gone through and corrected it here and on other golf courses.

137693072

Is that road still under construction on I-75?

137760191

Can you elaborate on your changeset comment? What did you do, why, etc.?

I would be more than happy to take a look.

137453944

Access tags should be used rather than mass-deleting features which clearly exist.

You can read more here on why they should be mapped:
osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property

changeset/137710101

129972208

Reverted changeset. Do not delete large chunks of a lake and incorrectly make it a water hazard for golf.

changeset/137709817

102258307

Same thing with this one.

Do not add in fake features for your golf game. Example:
way/917249653/history

This changeset has been reverted in part or full.

101020114

Do not add in fake features for your golf game. Example:
way/917249653/history

This changeset has been reverted in part or full.

137480195

When adding cartpaths, please use the cartpath tags instead of land access.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/137480195

137564047

Please do not change roadways to have a tunnel when this is not the case.

way/1183689606/history

136380403

"Fake" water hazards were removed. Please do not add fake and duplicate water areas for your golf game. This goes against OSM guidelines.

135911214

I think this should be reverted. I doubt it was actually discussed given that the user only has 3 edits.

There has been no attempt at resolving this changeset or addressing any of the issues identified. The many node lack a tag type and the name is abbreviated and all-caps.

I don't know the way to best fix the issues and given the low quality, I am not sure there is much benefit without any fix or cleanup.