Agree, sounds to me like this road can now be deleted.

Cheers
Chris

That's more interesting! Normally we go with the "on the ground rule" We have the Edinburgh OSM social tomorrow night (Guildford Arms from 7:30) so might check it out on the way over.

Not heard anything back - I walked past here and couldn't obviously see anything on the ground to verify this?

I think that I agree with _eric - Canmore also gives the name as "Scott Monument" https://canmore.org.uk/site/74114/edinburgh-princes-street-scott-monument

Hi - I think you need to have a discussion about these. I know we've had this discussion in the pub, and still I believe that as the tags aren't verifiable on the ground they shouldn't be mapped using the Primary ref tag. Dave F's proposal to move these to the highway_authority_ref does make sense. See the link above to the talk-gb thread.

Cheers
Chris

No problem - I'm assuming that you've been on holiday to Scotland? Hope you had a good trip and come back again to do some more mapping!

Cheers Sam - thanks for spotting the vandalism and signing up for an account to fix this!

Hi, thanks for signing up to OpenStreetMap and editing the map.

We don't always map Airbnb as they are not usually signposted and therefore can't easily be verified on the ground. In this case, however it would be great to get some more details at very least such as the full address and also get the point located more accuratly if possible?

Please let me know if you have any questions.

I think it';s worth having a discussion about how we tag these unsigned road references - their is a discussion on talk-gb: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2018-August/021690.html
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/61623830

That you for taking the time to add these. I do have a question about the Sandeman's Europe information point, I am wondering if there is anything permament here or is it just the start point for these tours?

Brilliant, thanks!

Hi, I see that you requested a review of this edit. Overall the edit looks great, I have a few small pointers to improve things further.

One simpolething to help improve buildings is to square the corners of buildings, this is simple achieved using the S key on the building.

The other details which isn't really intuiative is that we tend to put the name and other details on the school grounds and not the buildings themselves. This means that the name is only shown once and is useful for schools with multiple buildings etc. see the OSM wiki for more details amenity=school

Let me know if you have any questions.
Cheers
Chris

Hi, thanks for making the edit, I see that you requested a review and overall the change looks great. Their are a few things that aren't necessarily obvious that will improve things.

The first is very simple, it's nice to square off the building, this is simply a case of selecting the building in ID and using S to square it off.

The second, is that rather than associate the 20A-20E with the whole building is to add entrance nodes(points) where each entrance is.

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Cheers
Chris

Does this cycleway connect up withn The Parkway at the end, if so it's worth joping it up so that the routers will use it.

Hi thanks for the edit; I was wondering if you have any more details on this restuarant such as the address/opening hours or website?

Hi thanks ofr the edit. I see that you requested a review of your edit which looks great.

Cheers
Chris

Hi, I'm not local, but looking at the name "Memorial at Sanaigmore", just says where it is. I'm wondering if we should call this "Exmouth Memorial" as on this webpage? https://www.islayinfo.com/islay-walk-sanaigmore-bay.html

Hi Welcome to OpenStreetMap - Thanks for taking the time to sihn up and make an edit. I see that you requested a review and I've had a look and your edit looks perfect; and I'm looking forward to seeing more.

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Cheers
Chris

Hi thanks again, I've gone with the same idea here. Separating the hotel and restaurant.

Hi thanks for the edit, it looks great - I see that you requested a review. My only suggestion is to put the restaurant as an addition point inside the hotel outline. This way the building is shown as a hotel and the restuarant as an additional icon.