OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
146917714

Of course, it is you who wants to project. You call me a foreigner again. If you have documentation for your claim, take a photo of the place and upload it through mapillary. I will do the same. At the same time, I want all the editors to use the mapillary software to record such routes so that there is no room for doubt. We know that the name of Abu Mahdi al-Muhandis was added to the airport street and several other streets by the Iraqi government. But you keep deleting it. Editors, regardless of what they believe, have an obligation to record what is on the ground. You should not delete the efforts of others because it does not agree with your opinion.
Actually, there is a difference: you delete the name of the street and another user writes the name of the sign. Re-read the previous notes and read the wiki rules carefully to find out who is right. In addition, I have read the wiki rules and my work is not wrong, but your work is exactly wrong. The Kaaba is written in the same way in our language and you ignore the respect for the prophets. Regarding the wiki rule, you should read my note again: the new name is not ambiguous and people use it, and it is not a difficult name, and of course it is a new name, and the previous name is a local name with "loc name" and "old name" tags. It should be used, not removed. In fact, you have violated your word: even if we assume that the tag "official_name=*" should have been used, you have not used it either and you have completely removed the new name "جسر محمد باقر الصدر". And another user took pains and added it.

146917714

This feature is not vague or ambiguous. The new name here is not used at all. I have already reminded you of this wiki rule: when there is a naming dispute, the name on the board is used for the label. Therefore, you cannot delete the new name.
Regarding routing for other users: the name that existed before will not be deleted and will be placed in the "old name" tag. The rules of osm are quite clear, but you don't want to act according to them.
Regarding routing for other users: the name that existed before will not be deleted and will be placed in the "old name" tag. The rules of osm are quite clear, but you don't want to act according to them. Regarding your writing in Hebrew: it is enough for someone to check your edits to make everything clear. Regarding the example of the church and respect for religions: You have also removed my previous edits regarding the respectful suffix "عليه السلام" for imams, including Hazrat Adam, peace be upon him(عليه السلام), Noah, peace be upon him(عليه السلام), and Imam Ali, peace be upon him(عليه السلام).
About the boards: they exist but you call them informal with excuses. While they have been installed by the government.

146917714

On the same page as you say, if the name of the street is a point of dispute, we will use the sign on the street for the name label.

146917714

wiki osm:
.The most prominent name on a sign posted on the feature itself, especially for a feature in the built environment
.For disputed areas, please use the name as displayed on, e.g., street signs for the name tag

139255358

In all religions, they remember their leaders with respect. For example, in the church, instead of Maryam, it is written as The holy Maryam. Now you are preventing the word "عليه السلام" from being written after the names of the prophets.

139255358

You have even used the name in Hebrew in another place when there is no sign in Hebrew. Your actions are biased.

146749283

Definitely, in the future, the pictures of the target board will be added.
And as for the country of Iraq, I have done no disrespect to the people or the country of Iraq itself. I say that this country is definitely not an anarchy so that anyone can install something on the street.
When in reality there is a sign on the street level, then it should be recorded on the map.
You keep trying to sideline the discussion. Try to follow the osm wiki rules.
With respect to the people of Iraq

139255358

By the way, you did not pay attention to the writings and you should read it again.
I talk to you based on the rules, but you keep calling me a foreigner. Anyone can edit the map. It is not your paternal inheritance map. Wiki rules are the same everywhere.

139255358

It is stated in the wiki rules that adding the name of a city, street or shop in other languages helps Map Internationalization and is useful. But we must keep in mind that translation into another language does not change the content of the name in the original language.

139255358

It is mentioned in the link below that it is useful to register other languages.
osm.wiki/Names#Language-specific_names

139255358

I must say again, if you continue, give an example from the rules of the wiki. Do not do tasteful things.
Regards

139255358

If you insist on continuing this discussion, do so by citing the rules. For example, I mentioned the name of the city of Najaf, which is written in several other languages, and we do not have any writing in these languages on the signboard at the entrance of the city. So, in fact, there is nothing wrong with adding the name of any complication in several languages. Whether it is the name of a city or a street or a famous place in the world

139255358

Is the name of the city of Najaf written on the board in the 22 languages I mentioned in the previous note?
It is not mentioned in the osm rules that if the name of a city or street is not written in other languages on the board, no one is allowed to add another language. So, legally, you are not allowed to remove the "name" tag in other languages that are not in the board.

146749283

The new name of the streets is used in the tag "name" and the old name in "old name", the local name is used in "loc name", and if the tag "name" is long, it can be tagged "short name".

146749283

The wiki documentation does not contradict what I said. Have you polled that people use that name or do you have a problem with that name yourself? The sign that was recently installed here is an official sign, not a small or handwritten sign, and if it was not the official name, the municipality would have removed it. Why do you think Iraq is so chaotic that anyone can install whatever they want in the city? If a sign is installed on the street, it must be done with the permission of the municipality. But it seems that apart from the municipality, they should have asked permission from you too!! Meanwhile, OSM does not pursue political issues. In osm, we try to record every complication on the ground from whichever party we are.
At the same time, the writing on the board is not unfavorable or ambiguous. Unfavorability is your personal opinion.

139255358

If LockOnGuy's words are true, then we should not use other languages in the names of the cities because they are not in the board. But here you can see that the name of the city of Najaf is also written in 22 other languages...
node/348117530

139255358

LockOnGuy‏
To add the main name in the name tag, we need a panel. But to add the name of a place in several languages, we don't necessarily have to have a sign. For example, regarding the names of the cities, most of the countries that are active in osm are written in several languages, the name of that city is written on the map, although there is nothing recorded in the board in those languages. By the way, in response to you about my registrations having political reasons: By the way, you are the one who is deleting my registrations because of your taste and political reason. You call me a foreign user! In osm, any editor, regardless of which part of the world he is from, can edit according to the rules, and you cannot prevent this.

146749283

Hello
According to OSM rules, if the name of a street is written on the board, we cannot remove it for reasons or political taste. Anyway, in one of the name tags, the words on the board should be recorded.
In addition, we all know that Abu Mahdi Al-Muhandis was a general who rose up to fight against the DA'ESH terrorist group and sacrificed his life for his country, Iraq.
If you say in Wikipedia that he was a terrorist, we all know that Wikipedia is not impartial in political matters.

146677581

سلام
ضمن خداقوت در زحمت‌های شما، بنده گمان کردم مقصودتان از ۱۲۰ ،سرعت مسیر هست نه محل تابلو.
پاینده و سلامت باشید.

145565151

سلام و خداقوت
چراغ قرمز در یک نقطه از میدان وجود دارد. مابقی در ورودی هاست.