Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 123350903 | Is there a reason why you disconnected the two parts of Boulder Mountain Spur? They look connected in the aerial imagery. |
|
| 123298743 | This is the third copy of the Music Plus Learning Center you've added to the map. Is there a reason for this redundancy? |
|
| 123069193 | Sounds like the access should be "private", then: you can only use it with explicit permission. |
|
| 123069193 | "access=designated" doesn't make sense. "designated" is meant to be applied to specific modes of travel, such as "hgv=designated" to indicate a truck route. |
|
| 122927018 | The school name was already mapped on the school grounds. Unless the building has a different name than the school as a whole, there's no need to repeat it. |
|
| 122736802 | Traffic signs other than the common ones ("stop", "speed limit") are a fairly obscure topic. I'm pretty sure what you've got is the correct way to tag a "keep right" sign. |
|
| 121257703 | Thanks for the additions! When you added speed limits to these roads, you didn't indicate a unit, which causes the software to assume it's kilometers per hour. Am I correct in thinking that these should be marked as "miles per hour" rather than being some of the very few km/h speed limits in the US? |
|
| 122202388 | Why did you delete a restaurant that, by all evidence, still exists? |
|
| 122051851 | Thanks for the confirmation. |
|
| 122051851 | Are you sure the name is correct? The Spokane County streets department doesn't have a record of a street by that name there, while the assessor's office says the property has a "Park Lane" address. |
|
| 121665144 | Links to the Cebuano Wikipedia are almost never worth adding. As you noted, the articles are bot-generated. In the case of Teal Lake, the article is a mashup of geographic information (things like the approximate elevation of the lake, the county it's in, and the lake's distance from Washington, DC) and climate information of dubious accuracy algorithmically generated from a NASA dataset. |
|
| 121480349 | I keep an eye on the eastern Washington/northern Idaho area, and noticed your edit. The track/service distinction is one that a lot of people have trouble with, so I thought I'd leave a comment. "Original creator" frequently isn't useful information, particularly for roads: many of them were imported from US Census data about fifteen years ago. What's more useful is knowing who made the change you're interested in. The usual way to contact someone about an edit they made is to leave a comment on the changeset. When editing the map, you can access the history of an object by clicking the "map data" tab on the right-hand side (second one in the lower group) and selecting "show history panel". This will show you who edited the object most recently; the "history on osm.org" link will give you the complete history of the object, "changeset on osm.org" will give you details of the most recent edit to the object, and the "Osmcha" and "Achavi" links give graphical illustrations of the change. Welcome to OSM! |
|
| 121480349 | The "unmaintained" part of "unmaintained track road" isn't a strict requirement, but I agree it's a service road, not a logging or farm track. |
|
| 120989902 | Is there a reason why you deleted the island the 14th hole of the Coeur d'Alene Resort golf course is on? |
|
| 120815908 | Changing the address doesn't actually move anything: the map still had your business located at the corner of Canal and Auburn, just with a different address. I've moved it properly, by removing the business information from the old building and adding a business "point" object inside the new location. |
|
| 120807488 | I've reverted this changeset. It's too large for any of the QA tools to handle properly, but changing Burlington High School from a school to a nuclear explosion site suggests that it was not made in good faith. |
|
| 120210629 | I've reverted all of your changes except the very first one. If you continue to add nonsense to the map, you're likely to be blocked. |
|
| 120207769 | Please don't add random objects to the map. Instead, map what what actually exists. I've reverted this changeset. |
|
| 119757789 | Did you do any conflation before running this import? The very first thing I checked, node/9668520092, had already been mapped two months earlier. The second, node/9668520090, had been mapped five years earlier. I also find it unusual that both of them were tagged as "slaughterhouses": as far as I know, neither one kills animals. They both take already-processed carcasses and turn them into individual cuts of meat. |
|
| 119562802 | When you expand a node into a building like you did with Chaps Coffee Co., please make sure you copy all the information across, not just the name. |