Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 74758074 | Did you forget to change the name? |
|
| 74759489 | "Unmaintained track road" is meant for things like logging roads, not unpaved driveways. |
|
| 74762661 | Thanks for the addition! Are you sure the outline covers the entire park? Aerial imagery shows a couple of features to the west that look like they might be part of a playground. |
|
| 74685191 | Welcome to OSM! Since you requested a review, here are the things I noticed: * First and foremost, your changes are scattered across most of the Americas. This makes it difficult to review, and causes them to show up in the change history for many people. Make sure you save your changes every time you switch areas.
|
|
| 74615380 | Would "leisure=fishing" (leisure=fishing) be a reasonable tag for this? |
|
| 74501971 | Is there a reason why you deleted surface information from 52 roads here? |
|
| 74339270 | As far as I can tell, it's best described as "a weird historical accident". Back in 1888, one developer platted it as an extension of Oak Street, another platted it as an extension of Ash Street, and it never got built. But because the right-of-way provides the only access to a parcel at the south end, the city is required to maintain the potential for building a road there, even if it's only actually used as an informal driveway. |
|
| 74331421 | The "rest of the reservation" you added isn't part of the reservation, it's off-reservation trust land (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-reservation_trust_land), which is a very different thing. |
|
| 74318288 | The pavement on these streets is brick. I went there and looked. |
|
| 74277814 | Is "maxspeed:forward" really the correct tag here? Roads where the speed limit varies with direction are quite rare. |
|
| 74232571 | Is the speed limit on WA-261 really 35 mph for the whole distance you've tagged? |
|
| 74198257 | You've been making these mistakes every few days for quite a while. Please figure out what you're doing wrong and stop doing it. |
|
| 74193635 | Most tools don't care if you spell it "FIXME", "fixme", or "FixMe", they'll alert on any variation of capitalization. |
|
| 74182841 | Thanks for helping keep things up-to-date! A quick request: please don't abbreviate things. It's easy for a computer to create an abbreviation if it needs to save space, but automatically expanding an abbreviation is much harder. For example, should "St." be expanded to "Street", "State", or "Saint"? |
|
| 74098442 | Please be more careful when editing large relations like this. You both broke the Lolo National Forest boundary and left the reservation boundary in an incomplete state. |
|
| 74072556 | Where are you getting the information that Prichard Creek Road/FS 9 is a secondary road? It hasn't been an important part of the road network since gold mining ended a century ago -- they don't even bother to plow it past Murray in the winter. |
|
| 74062381 | Have you confirmed the accuracy of the shapefile you used? Some of the Forest Service trail maps have rather serious errors, such as running along the wrong side of a lake, or having junctions a mile or more from the actual location. |
|
| 73772087 | GIS data isn't infalliable. The "44th Avenue" you added is a private driveway. |
|
| 73727672 | What's your source for the road not being there? I've driven or hiked on quite a few roads (such as way/13920613 and the surrounding tracks) that the Forest Service shows as not being there. Judging from the surface quality shown in the Esri Clarity imagery, I think I could get my Civic through there, though I probably wouldn't be going very fast. |
|
| 73729325 | I'm pretty sure that what you've mapped is just a barn, and the grange hall is the blue-roofed building across the street. |