OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
77849397

s/Traffic/Drive

77752436

Machine translation to Russian is as follows:

Источник названий улиц, пожалуйста?

Вы добавили много названий улиц в штате Келантан Малайзии. Не могли бы вы предоставить свой источник для этого?

Заранее спасибо.

77752436

Where did you get the street names please?

73990842

Many thanks for your response. Anyway, just curious, are you any way related to Maxim, the ride sharing company?

73990842

Could you please state from where you get all street names please?

73991886

Source of street names please?

73951347

Hello, regarding to your edit around this area (refer changeset/73951347#map=16/6.2788/100.4259), may I know what is your source to determine the route reference number?

50037237

Unclassified highways:

way/368483382 (way/368483382/) leads to some residential and a row of shops adjacent to it. I cannot see why it should be downgraded to a residential highway. On top of that, it was surveyed by me a few years ago. (way/368483382/)

way/505084044 (way/505084044) may well be downgraded to a residential highway. There was probably no better imagery available when I mapped it.

way/255520065 (way/255520065/history) was mapped by a cyclist passing by this highway, so therefore, it's coming from ground truth.

way/391065168 (way/391065168) probably is best downgraded as a residential highway too.

50037237

Tracks:

way/619486495 (way/619486495) could be mapped as highway=service + service=driveway from the adjacent primary road up until node/6639966921 (node/6639966921)

way/255520054 (way/255520054/) is clearly mapped by a cyclist who went through the track 5 years ago (changeset/19841040). I believe it remains a track, and not even a suitable highway to be traversed by cars.

way/484975143 (way/484975143) was surveyed by me, back in 2017 (changeset/47483083)

72536419

Salam, bukan orang KL. Boleh tahu Kementah (way/706536788/history) ni tempat yang macam mana?

72537140

Hello, some feedback on your edits:

This particular way (way/706542305) was readded in this edit. Source: https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=72537140

Please take a look on these pictures: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blocks_placed_to_block_a_road.jpg and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blocked_U_turn.jpg which represents the ground truth of this particular way.

The highway is blocked, so therefore I don't map it as an existing highway.

65078491

Alright, fair justification. Please make appropriate changes for these highways.

35198311

I surveyed this highway myself and collected the GPS track for it. In addition, between 2003 and 2007, I used to pass this highway as well. So, that's why I justified this highway as a highway=unclassified rather than highway=residential.

21582790

Hi. Fair enough, please adjust accordingly.

43302185

As the one who mapped these highways from collecting my own GPS tracks: best if they are left as they were

22954983

Second comment:

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Zw4uMecbsV8/XTbPQc5-6_I/AAAAAAAAAaY/uosKw8UJKv4C9VUL1XBh5HAs6a01SHWEQCK8BGAs/s0/2019-07-23.png

those two links should be left as they are: they connect to the adjacent highway=trunk. And they are links connecting to the adjacent highway going in/out of the residential area.

Sorry for the delay getting in touch with the team.

22954983

First comment: assuming you are pointing on this way (way/288251491). Please make suitable change to the higher classification (highway=unclassified) between these nodes: node/2918121022 and node/5921176441. Beyond the latter node, the highway should be splitted up as a highway=residential.

72759685

This issue might also affect every potential highways which have been mapped as highway=unclassified or highway=residential.

Please, hopefully your team's edits are re-reviewed.

72759685

I would like to draw attention to your mapping team: be extra careful to map potential highways in this area with paddy fields surrounding it.

For example, this highway (way/708427243) was mapped as an unclassified highway.

I drive around this area a few times a month. Usually highways adjacent to canals are merely dirt track for agricultural purposes. It may appear quite prominent, e.g. http://osmz.ru/imagery/#17/5.87901/100.44482/mp (from the imagery) but please, please take extra care.

I hope your team would begin fix this issue. Please let me know when it's completed.

18758847

Go ahead and fine tune these ways (way/245017827, way/245017847)