OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
110405803

I make this change because of the inspire of this Pull Request in NSI on github:(https://github.com/osmlab/name-suggestion-index/pull/5283)

I think you want to type "kebab" so I do this changes, If not suitable, just revert this changeset and meke "kebap" again.

104607365

We will pause deleting population for a while, but I think you can ask DWG for those china_population problem.(The solver should be familiar with China problem)(Here are votes for this new tag:osm.wiki/Proposed_features/china_population

Maybe call DWG will be ultimate and put an end to this problem, because we didn’t want to be enemies of world editors at first

104607365

If we fight with render developer, I hope that those comment in this changesets can be evidences for edit render way.
(And wish someone "fixing population"can help to improve render)

104607365

You should judge what level of place it is based on adminlevel, not based on population.
Population is inaccurate. China’s population is completely different from that of the West. The accusation of china_population is based on the stereotype of the Western model’s global promotion.
This is data tyranny. So will you face the true problem we faced? You helped? You only removed!

104607365

Here is a question usually talked.
A is a county level town with 2000K people, B is a prefecture level city with 300K people, which should be prefered?

104607365

> this is not a valid reason to remove correct tags, such as population tags

Do you still think this is correct? What is correct?
The correct way is to face the complexity of China's administrative level and significantly larger population than a western town, to use more region defined tag to render correct, instead of accusing others of "your tag is wrong"

Using this way to tag is to solve problem, not create problem

104607365

This changeset will be revert immediately as the same way you revert it.

104607365

Deat Mateusz Konieczny:
Please stop your singal revert.
This tag is to preserve exact population data not removed by other mapper, because they will think osmcarto do wrong render by population.
If render is not suitable and you find they are hard to communite (not say issue, you can't know how stubborn those people are), the only way is change a tag to describe, utill one day they use correct way to render.

If you still think "do not tag for render" is strict and can't violate by anyway, at any situation,
We only can say that correct render of administrive is strict to us too, and to satisfy your request for "correct tag way"
And, at that time, population and china_population all will be removed, so render is OK, your "guideline" is OK, leave data-completeness to be the victim, will that world you dream?

110125075

Hey brother, it looks like you are not malicious, but maybe you really don't understand China's administrative divisions, which are more complicated than what Key:place in OSM can provide, so we use the Key:china_class to improve administrative divisions. If you have paid attention to the guide in Key:admin_level, it will also remind you to refer to the Chinese document first.
In order to better repair the previous data, please suspend the modification of administrative jurisdiction in Western China. Thank you very much for your understanding, and thanks for your knowledge in local language.

110206370

note/605892
Name from this

110206280

已根据note/2329765
修订了六年前的设施

109735069

The things you ask is about GLOBAL EDIT, that is what you first ask me for.
You only comment on my changesets, other mapper's global edits are not be hot pursued.
For the original question GLOBAL EDIT, you are accusing baselessly becaues guide in OSM don't say you should ban a global edit, here!(osm.wiki/FAQ)

(Reply for changeset/109747676 are all in there)

110182826

Don't delete node in no case, that will cause data lose in OSM, stop your vandalism operation!

109725753

Why not ask wheelmap.org not do this? It bother everyone automatically everyday.

109735069

If you have trouble, why not go to ask wheelmap.org not do this? This website do global mapping day and day and day. If you see "history" it will give you a lot of global changesets from this website, it will bother you more than my seldom changes.
It is because I'm Chinese, so you become angry and go there to shut me "not do that"!

109747676

If you have trouble, why not go to ask wheelmap.org not do this? This website do global mapping day and day and day.
Because I'm Chinese, so you are angry and go there to shut me "not do that"!

110121856

您好!贵州地区的编辑者!您可能发现您的地级市或县级市的名称发生了变化,英文或者拼音的名称被去掉了,英文部分也仅保留了名称而去掉了通名。这是按照中文OSM社区的多语言标注规则进行的,望您谅解。
更多内容请查看:osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China

110121710

您好!贵州地区的编辑者!您可能发现您的地级市或县级市的名称发生了变化,英文或者拼音的名称被去掉了,英文部分也仅保留了名称而去掉了通名。这是按照中文OSM社区的多语言标注规则进行的,望您谅解。
更多内容请查看:osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China

110121557

您好!贵州地区的编辑者!您可能发现您的地级市或县级市的名称发生了变化,英文或者拼音的名称被去掉了,英文部分也仅保留了名称而去掉了通名。这是按照中文OSM社区的多语言标注规则进行的,望您谅解。
更多内容请查看:osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China

110121322

您好!贵州地区的编辑者!您可能发现您的地级市或县级市的名称发生了变化,英文或者拼音的名称被去掉了,英文部分也仅保留了名称而去掉了通名。这是按照中文OSM社区的多语言标注规则进行的,望您谅解。
更多内容请查看:osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China