OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
59855935

переделываю

60050436

вы не должны решать в чем есть необходимость, а в чем нет, если обозначено верно

60050751

откатываю

60050835

это не будет работать

60191030

откатываю целиком, всё не так.

59877782

Добрый день!
пожалуйста не используйте тег crossing=zebra
вот тут подробно описано почему
osm.wiki/RU:Key:crossing

60001791

Добрый день!
было бы лучше, если вы отредактировали уже существующую точку.

60001720

а 17 подъезд точно там? на гуглопанорамах от 16 года там ничего нет. https://goo.gl/maps/kg9FQxiyKPp

51568571

это ваш дом?

59983238

No. If someone tags object with right and wrong tags, wrong tags should be deleted. You make classic mistakes of justification wrong tags for renderer.

39293617

Добрый день!
насчет дома, где останавливался пушкин. там висит табличка?

59983238

this is wrong data only for 3d renderers. :/

59983238

This is changeset war. I'l report to DWG

59935199

nice!
let's go deeper.
1) osm.wiki/Simple_3D_buildings
>This page describes tags for basic 3D attributes of buildings.
>buildings
So, building:part on non buildings still not valid.
2)it is an object itself, of course! I didn't say it is not. Thats why it has
tourism attraction
attraction big_wheel

just like WIkiOSM says us:
tourism=attraction
osm.wiki/Proposed_features/Key:attraction

59935199

osm.wiki/Buildings#Don.27t_tag_for_the_renderer
> tagging e.g. statues, bridge piers, gravestones or sockets as buildings to make them visible on the map. This can be counterproductive even for 3D-Mapping.

Such manipulations damage not only the OSM, but also they are needless, because their effect is usually limited to a single renderer, which will be probably modified soon.

59935199

I'm not trying fix f4map. I'm trying to fix wrong data! Flyer wheel itself is not building, which should be tagged with building=*.
This is just tagging for renderer, nothing else.

50758126

почему через "и"?

50494869

пожалуйста, опишите подробно что это.

59935199

please, describe which part of the wheel is building?
let's compare. This is screenshot of f4map renderer:
http://piccy.info/view3/12425147/66aaffd4d03b4f8fac83e777040927a3/orig/
there you can see part of 3d implementation of wheel on the right side with actual proprietary 3d model. They don't look similar, aren't they?
tagging for renderer is that you tag object somehow just to look it on the renderer. for example, many people tag aircrafts, ships and other objects with tag building=*

59935199

wheel is not a building osm.wiki/RU:Key:building.
Also that 3d implemenation was completely wrong. And finally that is osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer