"Should I tag the street or draw a separate way?"
Posted by Ævar Arnfjörð Bjarmason on 17 November 2009 in English.Whether we should tag streets indicating whether it has an associated footway/cycleway is a discussion that comes up again and again on OpenStreetMap forums. Currently there's an ongoing discussion on the mailing list for Denmark discussing whether or not the cycleways in Copenhagen should be represented as cycleway=lane tags on the streets or as separate highway=cycleway ways alongside the street.
Rather than discuss that specific issue I think it's worth stepping back and thinking about it makes sense to represent the sort of complex map data we're likely to get in the future where we want to accurately represent highways, pedestrian areas, intersections and other things like that.
Right now most intersections in OSM look like this:
These ways may or may not have an associated pedestrian pavement.
Here's the same intersection with added pedestrian ways & crossings:







